Hi all…the Grand River and its tributaries in southern Ontario have been, and continue to be, very intensely studied. The latest published paper describes temporal trends in Giardia oocyst occurrence. Strikingly, but not unexpectedly, the authors found that Giardia cysts were identified in 89% of samples, with highest measured concentrations downstream of a wastewater treatment plant outfall. The good news for drinking water providers is that seasonal peaks in Giardia cyst concentrations in samples collected near the intake for the drinking water plant did not align with the seasonal peak in human Giardiasis cases. This suggests that the “risk of contracting Giardiasis from treated drinking water in this community is possibly low when the treatment plant is functioning adequately.” Instead, waterborne exposure is likely the result of seasonal behaviours surrounding recreational water use.
They also report an association which hasn’t previously been reported that I’m aware of, that being dissolved oxygen was the only variable significantly associated with Giardia cyst concentration (even after controlling for season, year and sampling location)!
Bill
__________________________________________________________________
Temporal trends in Giardia occurrence in the Grand River and surrounding tributaries, Waterloo, Ontario (2005–2013), a retrospective analysis of surveillance data
L. Swirski, D. L. Pearl, A. S. Peregrine, J. Thomas, and K. Pintar
Zoonoses Public Health. 2017; 1–13.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/zph.12388/abstract
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/10.1111/(ISSN)1863-2378/earlyview
Summary
“Giardia contamination in the Grand River Watershed (south-western Ontario, Canada) was monitored from 2005 to 2013 as part of FoodNet Canada. Our study objectives were to describe the temporal pattern of Giardia occurrence and determine whether water quality parameters and bacterial indicators could act as effective markers for Giardia occurrence. Water samples were collected monthly from the Grand River near a drinking water intake point (2005–2013) and also collected intermittently from other areas in the watershed during the study period. Samples were tested for Giardia cysts using the US EPA method 1623. Samples were also tested for chemical and microbial water quality indicators. Univariable and multivariable linear regression models were built to examine whether temporal, water quality and bacterial indicators were associated with Giardia cyst concentration. Giardia cysts were identified in 89% of samples (n = 228), with highest measured concentrations downstream of a waste water treatment plant outfall. Year and season were found to be predictors for Giardia occurrence. Concentrations were significantly higher in the winter and fall compared to the summer, and significantly higher in 2007 compared to other study years. After controlling for season, year and sampling location, dissolved oxygen was the only variable significantly associated with Giardia cyst concentration. Seasonal peaks in Giardia cyst concentrations in samples collected near the intake for the drinking water plant did not align with the seasonal peak in human Giardiasis cases in this region that are reported annually by public health authorities. This suggests that the risk of contracting Giardiasis from treated drinking water in this community is possibly low when the treatment plant is functioning adequately. Instead, waterborne exposure is likely the result of seasonal behaviours surrounding recreational water use. Therefore, the collective findings of our study are important to help inform future risk management studies and guide public health protection policies.”
